Update

We ended up going with a hybrid of Candidates A & F ...
soffit & post
Sherwin-Williams Roycroft Suede
crown
Sherwin-Williams Polished Mahogany
gutter
Martha Stewart Griddle Gray
window trim
Sherwin-Williams Roycroft Suede
window sash
Sherwin-Williams Polished Mahogany

Click here to see photos of our progress.



Candidate A

soffit & post
Sherwin-Williams Roycroft Suede
crown & gutter
Sherwin-Williams Polished Mahogany
window trim
Sherwin-Williams Roycroft Suede
window sash
Sherwin-Williams Polished Mahogany
Candidate1.jpg

Candidate B

soffit & post
Sherwin-Williams Roycroft Suede
crown & gutter
Sherwin-Williams Polished Mahogany
window trim
Sherwin-Williams Roycroft Suede
window sash
Sherwin-Williams Roycroft Bronze Green
Candidate3.jpg

Candidate C

soffit & post
Sherwin-Williams Roycroft Suede
crown & gutter
Sherwin-Williams Polished Mahogany
window trim
Sherwin-Williams Roycroft Bronze Green
window sash
Sherwin-Williams Polished Mahogany
Candidate4.jpg

Candidate D

soffit
Sherwin-Williams Roycroft Brass
post
Sherwin-Williams Roycroft Suede
crown & gutter
Sherwin-Williams Polished Mahogany
window trim
Sherwin-Williams Roycroft Brass
window sash
Sherwin-Williams Roycroft Suede
Candidate6.jpg

Candidate E

soffit & post
Sherwin-Williams Roycroft Suede
crown & gutter
Martha Stewart Griddle Gray
window trim
Sherwin-Williams Roycroft Suede
window sash
Sherwin-Williams Roycroft Bronze Green
  • (post color is somewhat off in this image)
Candidate7.jpg

Candidate F

soffit & post
Sherwin-Williams Roycroft Suede
crown & gutter
Martha Stewart Griddle Gray
window trim
Sherwin-Williams Roycroft Suede
window sash
Sherwin-Williams Polished Mahogany
  • (post color is somewhat off in this image)
Candidate8.jpg

Candidate G

soffit & post
Sherwin-Williams Roycroft Pewter
crown & gutter
Sherwin-Williams Polished Mahogany
window trim
Sherwin-Williams Roycroft Pewter
window sash
Sherwin-Williams Polished Mahogany
Candidate5.jpg

Candidate H

soffit & post
Sherwin-Williams Roycroft Pewter
crown & gutter
Martha Stewart's Griddle Gray
window trim
Sherwin-Williams Roycroft Pewter
window sash
Sherwin-Williams Polished Mahogany
Candidate9.jpg